Tables
The failure modesHow an approved decision can fail
An approved decision can fail in recognisable ways. Each failure mode belongs to a phase of the Spiral, and each appears in a public record written up as a Kettei case.
The failure modes, with a case for each
| Failure mode | What it looks like | In the record |
|---|---|---|
| Decision Vacancy | No single person holds the decision's continuing validity. "Who is driving this?" | UK Ajax armoured vehicle |
| Authority Capture | Authority taken in a crisis stays after the crisis, and commitments made inside execution go undeclared | Prevention of Terrorism Act |
| Strategic-Tactical Chasm | A board decision reaches delivery as a task list, with no scope or conditions the people doing the work can govern against | Target Canada |
| Coupling Blindness | 2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. One changes and the other does not hear | Novopay |
| Unforged Governance | A practice is adopted and adapted before anyone drilled it to competence | GM and NUMMI |
| Documentation-Reality Divergence | The written process and the process people actually run have separated | Piper Alpha |
| Capability-Governance Mismatch | Decision authority grows faster than the capability to govern it | Uber |
| Assumption Drift | The world moved and the decision stayed put. "We decided this last year." | Peloton |
| Trigger Register Decay | Triggers are written down, and the register goes unwatched | Equifax |
| Normalisation of Deviance | Deviations become background noise. "That error rate is normal for us." | Challenger |
| Signals Ignored | The trigger fires and the owner does not act | Mid Staffordshire NHS Trust |
| Escalation of Commitment | Persisting because of what has been spent. "We have come too far to stop." | Taurus, London Stock Exchange |
| Ungoverned Persistence | No triggers and no abort criteria, so the organisation has no definition of when to stop | Knight Capital |
| Governance Theatre | Dashboards green and forums held, with no decision changed by either | Carillion |
| Reflection Theatre | The post-mortem is filed, and 12 months later the same failure recurs | Columbia |
| Institutional Moralisation | Questioning the decision reads as questioning the institution, so it goes unrevalidated | Post Office Horizon |
From Decision Ownership After the Rubber Stamp, November 2026. The cases rest on inquiry reports, regulators' findings, court judgments and company filings.
The table as first published, by phase

| Phase | Failure mode | What it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Decide | Decision Vacancy | No single person holds the decision's continuing validity. "Who is driving this?" |
| Decide | Authority Capture | Authority taken in a crisis stays after the crisis, and commitments made inside execution are never declared as decisions. |
| Decide | Strategic-Tactical Chasm | A board decision reaches delivery as a task list, with no scope or conditions the people doing the work can govern against. |
| Decide | Coupling Blindness | 2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. One changes and the other never hears. |
| Forge | Unforged Governance | A practice is adopted and adapted before anyone drilled it to competence. |
| Forge | Documentation-Reality Divergence | The written process and the process people actually run have separated. |
| Forge | Capability-Governance Mismatch | Decision authority grows faster than the capability to govern it. |
| Persist | Assumption Drift | The world moved and the decision stayed put. "We decided this last year." |
| Persist | Trigger Register Decay | Triggers sit on paper and nobody watches the register. |
| Persist | Normalisation of Deviance | Deviations become background noise. "That error rate is normal for us." |
| Persist | Signals Ignored | The trigger fires and the owner does not act. |
| Persist | Escalation of Commitment | Persisting because of what has been spent. "We have come too far to stop." |
| Persist | Ungoverned Persistence | No triggers and no abort criteria, so nothing defines when to stop. |
| Reflect | Governance Theatre | Every dashboard green and every forum held, with no decision ever changed by either. |
| Reflect | Reflection Theatre | The post-mortem is filed, and 12 months later the same failure recurs. |
| Reflect | Institutional Moralisation | Questioning the decision reads as questioning the institution, so it is never revalidated. |
Kettei Workshop: The Board Question
POA. Email for details.
