Tables

The failure modesHow an approved decision can fail

An approved decision can fail in recognisable ways. Each failure mode belongs to a phase of the Spiral, and each appears in a public record written up as a Kettei case.

The failure modes, with a case for each

Failure modeWhat it looks likeIn the record
Decision VacancyNo single person holds the decision's continuing validity. "Who is driving this?"UK Ajax armoured vehicle
Authority CaptureAuthority taken in a crisis stays after the crisis, and commitments made inside execution go undeclaredPrevention of Terrorism Act
Strategic-Tactical ChasmA board decision reaches delivery as a task list, with no scope or conditions the people doing the work can govern againstTarget Canada
Coupling Blindness2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. One changes and the other does not hearNovopay
Unforged GovernanceA practice is adopted and adapted before anyone drilled it to competenceGM and NUMMI
Documentation-Reality DivergenceThe written process and the process people actually run have separatedPiper Alpha
Capability-Governance MismatchDecision authority grows faster than the capability to govern itUber
Assumption DriftThe world moved and the decision stayed put. "We decided this last year."Peloton
Trigger Register DecayTriggers are written down, and the register goes unwatchedEquifax
Normalisation of DevianceDeviations become background noise. "That error rate is normal for us."Challenger
Signals IgnoredThe trigger fires and the owner does not actMid Staffordshire NHS Trust
Escalation of CommitmentPersisting because of what has been spent. "We have come too far to stop."Taurus, London Stock Exchange
Ungoverned PersistenceNo triggers and no abort criteria, so the organisation has no definition of when to stopKnight Capital
Governance TheatreDashboards green and forums held, with no decision changed by eitherCarillion
Reflection TheatreThe post-mortem is filed, and 12 months later the same failure recursColumbia
Institutional MoralisationQuestioning the decision reads as questioning the institution, so it goes unrevalidatedPost Office Horizon

From Decision Ownership After the Rubber Stamp, November 2026. The cases rest on inquiry reports, regulators' findings, court judgments and company filings.

The table as first published, by phase

Table: the Kettei failure modes by phase, with what each looks like, as published on 1 October 2026
The table published in Kettei: After the Thud of a Rubber Stamp, 1 October 2026.
PhaseFailure modeWhat it looks like
DecideDecision VacancyNo single person holds the decision's continuing validity. "Who is driving this?"
DecideAuthority CaptureAuthority taken in a crisis stays after the crisis, and commitments made inside execution are never declared as decisions.
DecideStrategic-Tactical ChasmA board decision reaches delivery as a task list, with no scope or conditions the people doing the work can govern against.
DecideCoupling Blindness2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. One changes and the other never hears.
ForgeUnforged GovernanceA practice is adopted and adapted before anyone drilled it to competence.
ForgeDocumentation-Reality DivergenceThe written process and the process people actually run have separated.
ForgeCapability-Governance MismatchDecision authority grows faster than the capability to govern it.
PersistAssumption DriftThe world moved and the decision stayed put. "We decided this last year."
PersistTrigger Register DecayTriggers sit on paper and nobody watches the register.
PersistNormalisation of DevianceDeviations become background noise. "That error rate is normal for us."
PersistSignals IgnoredThe trigger fires and the owner does not act.
PersistEscalation of CommitmentPersisting because of what has been spent. "We have come too far to stop."
PersistUngoverned PersistenceNo triggers and no abort criteria, so nothing defines when to stop.
ReflectGovernance TheatreEvery dashboard green and every forum held, with no decision ever changed by either.
ReflectReflection TheatreThe post-mortem is filed, and 12 months later the same failure recurs.
ReflectInstitutional MoralisationQuestioning the decision reads as questioning the institution, so it is never revalidated.

Kettei Workshop: The Board Question

POA. Email for details.