Kettei term

Resulting

Resulting is judging a decision by its result. Annie Duke borrowed the word from poker in Thinking in Bets, and a governed review guards against it by reading what was declared at the start before it reads the outcome.

Duke opens Thinking in Bets, published in 2018, on a play call at the end of Super Bowl XLIX. The pass was intercepted, and the next day's headlines called it the worst play call in Super Bowl history. She reports that of 66 passes thrown that season from an opponent's one-yard line, "zero had been intercepted."

Her diagnosis of the critics is a tendency to "equate the quality of a decision with the quality of its outcome", and poker players have a name for it, resulting. A sound strategy loses hands in the short run, and a player who abandons it after a few bad ones has learned from luck. Duke names the companion error as hindsight bias, the sense once an outcome is known that it was bound to happen.

In an organisation

Reviews inside organisations face the same pull under whatever name the agenda gives. A retrospective, a post-implementation review or a lessons-learned session examines what happened. Once the outcome sets the agenda, a sound decision that went badly is likely to be rewritten, and a decision that went well tends to escape scrutiny altogether.

Duke's own example is a chief executive who named the firing of his company's president as his worst decision of the year, because sales were falling. His peers agreed the decision was reasonable on what was known when it was made. By then he had already changed how he made later decisions on the strength of the result.

What Kettei asks

Kettei's Reflect phase, Hansei, opens on the decision record. It is invoked when the validity horizon expires and after an abort, and its governed question, asked irrespective of outcome, is whether the decision still holds. A fired trigger gets its answer sooner, in flight, from the decision's Owner.

The Watchcard holds what was declared at Decide, among it the named Owner, the assumptions and horizon that make up the validity boundary, the triggers and the abort criteria. Hansei reads those declarations before it reads the result. The result still enters a Hansei, as evidence about an assumption.

The phase ends in a verdict, which is to Recommit, Pivot or Release. Whichever verdict is committed goes on the record with the evidence that produced it. A governed review leaves a state and its evidence where the next Owner can read it and dispute it. The Kettei Card serves the same purpose from the other end, by recording the rationale and the knowledge when the decision is made.

The question to ask

The test can be run on a past decision with the result covered and the declarations read alone. Does the record of this decision show whether it still holds?

Read the original

Resulting was published on Kettei on Substack on 11 November 2026, and is gathered in Kettei Decision Digest 6: Failures of Honesty. The personal form of the Reflect phase is set out at Hansei on ishi.co.nz.

Sources

  1. Duke, A. (2018) Thinking in Bets: Making Smarter Decisions When You Don't Have All the Facts. New York: Portfolio. Chapter 1, "Life Is Poker, Not Chess". The source of the term and of the examples above.

From the essay Resulting on Kettei on Substack, 11 November 2026.

The cover of Kettei: The Discipline of Governed Intent by Gareth A Holebrook

Kettei

The Discipline of Governed Intent